Every organization has values. They appear on websites, in strategic plans, during onboarding, and across conference room walls. Integrity, compassion, collaboration, accountability, innovation, and respect are among the most common. These values are important because they communicate what the organization aspires to become. But there is a difference between the values an organization declares and the values employees experience.
Consider an organization that celebrates collaboration but consistently promotes individuals who achieve results at the expense of their colleagues. Another declares psychological safety a priority but treats disagreement with senior leadership as disloyalty. In each case, the organization communicates two messages: one through its words and another through its decisions. When organizational values and organizational rewards contradict one another, employees learn which message matters more.
This is not necessarily a problem of dishonesty. Leaders may genuinely believe in the values they communicate. The difficulty is that organizational culture is shaped not only by intentions but also by repeated experiences. Employees observe who receives recognition, whose behavior is tolerated, which concerns receive attention, and what happens when organizational principles become inconvenient. Over time, these experiences form an understanding of how the organization actually operates.
Edgar Schein’s work on organizational culture helps explain this phenomenon. Schein (2010) distinguished between espoused values and the deeper assumptions that shape organizational behavior. What leaders say matters, but the patterns they reinforce through decisions, attention, and resource allocation may reveal more about the culture employees encounter. Similarly, research on organizational justice demonstrates that employees’ perceptions of fairness are associated with important workplace attitudes and behaviors (Colquitt et al., 2001).
At SWEET Institute, the Four Layers of Transformation provide a framework for examining the distance between stated values and lived experience.
At the Conscious Layer, we identify the organization’s declared principles and the formal practices intended to support them. Are expectations clear? Are values reflected in performance evaluations, hiring decisions, promotions, and policies?
At the Preconscious Layer, we explore how employees experience those principles in everyday interactions. When someone raises a concern, makes a mistake, requests support, or challenges a decision, does the response reflect the values leadership promotes?
At the Unconscious Layer, we examine the assumptions and incentives that may contradict the organization’s intentions. Perhaps leadership values collaboration but measures success almost exclusively through individual productivity. Perhaps compassion is celebrated while managers are rewarded primarily for reducing costs. Perhaps innovation is encouraged, yet mistakes associated with experimentation are punished. These contradictions can persist because they have become familiar, normalized, or embedded in established systems.
At the Existential Layer, we ask the deeper question: Who are we becoming through the behaviors we repeatedly recognize, reward, and tolerate?
This question is especially important because organizational culture is not created through declarations alone. It is reinforced through choices. Every promotion communicates something about what leadership values. Every exception to a policy communicates something about fairness. Every response to a mistake communicates something about accountability. Every decision involving competing priorities communicates something about what matters when values are tested.
Imagine a high-performing manager who consistently achieves financial and operational targets but repeatedly undermines colleagues, dismisses employee concerns, and creates unnecessary fear. If that manager continues receiving promotions and recognition without meaningful accountability, employees receive a powerful message. Regardless of what the organization says about respect and collaboration, results appear to excuse harmful behavior. The organization may not intend to communicate that message, but its decisions make the lesson difficult to miss.
The opposite is equally powerful. When leaders recognize employees who collaborate across departments, raise concerns constructively, support colleagues, and improve systems rather than merely producing impressive individual results, they demonstrate that organizational values have practical consequences. Values become credible when people can see them influencing decisions, especially when honoring them requires making a difficult choice.
This is where the SWEET four-step leadership rhythm becomes useful.
We Stabilize by identifying where contradictions between stated values and actual practices are creating confusion or mistrust.
We Reframe by moving beyond the question of whether employees understand the organization’s values toward whether the organization consistently demonstrates them.
We Decide with Clarity and Transparency by aligning recognition, accountability, performance evaluation, and leadership decisions with those principles.
Finally, we Align Work with Purpose by ensuring that the organization’s everyday practices reflect the mission it claims to serve.
This work is central to the Beyond Burnout 12-Month Leadership Cohort because misalignment between stated values and lived experience can become a significant source of frustration and disengagement. Employees may enter an organization inspired by its mission, only to encounter practices that contradict the principles that attracted them.
Over time, this discrepancy can erode trust and weaken commitment. Sustainable engagement requires more than meaningful language. It requires organizational conditions that make those meanings credible.
Here is the question for your leadership team this week: If employees could identify our values only by observing whom we promote, what we reward, what we tolerate, and how we make difficult decisions, what values would they conclude we actually hold?
Compare those answers with the values displayed on your website. Where they align, reinforce what is working. Where they differ, resist the temptation to rewrite the values statement. Begin by changing the decisions and practices that communicate something different.
The Call to Action
The Beyond Burnout 12-Month Leadership Cohort helps agency leaders move beyond aspirational culture statements toward organizational alignment, examining how leadership decisions, incentives, accountability, and everyday practices shape employee experience and sustainable performance.
We Stabilize, Reframe, Decide with Clarity and Transparency, Align Work with Purpose. Because values are not simply what an organization says it believes. They are what people repeatedly experience through the choices leadership makes.
Your organization’s values are written on its walls. Its real values are revealed by what happens within them.
References
Colquitt, J. A., Conlon, D. E., Wesson, M. J., Porter, C. O. L. H., & Ng, K. Y. (2001). Justice at the millennium: A meta-analytic review of 25 years of organizational justice research. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86(3), 425–445. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.86.3.425
Schein, E. H. (2010). Organizational culture and leadership (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.
